Could Skating Judge’s Comments Backfire on U.S.?

The Winter Olympics in Vancouver haven’t even officially begun, and a figure skating controversy is already brewing.

According to Canadian newspaper Globe and Mail, veteran American skating judge Joe Inman has been accused of bias against European skaters after he sent a series of e-mails to some 60 international judges and officials, some of whom would be involved with the Vancouver Games, reminding them to mark presentation scores accurately.

Inman sent the e-mails after he heard Russia’s Evengi Plushenko, the reigning Olympic champion, say in an interview after the European championships, “If the judges want someone to place high, they can arrange it.” Plushenko also admitted in the interview that he and Frenchman Brian Joubert do not have transitions in their programs because they focus on their jumps. Both Joubert and Plushenko have been criticized for their lack of transitions in their program, though judges continue to score them well in their component scores.

Inman’s e-mails were picked up by a French sports publication which published a story about them with a headline that read “The Hostilities Begin.” The article suggested that Inman was leading a lobby of North American judges against European skaters, a charge that baffled Inman, who says the e-mails were meant to be instructional in nature and were not meant to stir up controversy. Inman is one of the creators of the current scoring system and teaches other judges about how to assess skaters’ performances and score them accurately.

The timing of this controversy cannot be good. While the European skating community accuses North American bias against their skaters, one wonders if there will be a backlash against North American skaters. Would European judges underscore leading skaters like Canada’s Patrick Chan and American Evan Lysacek while bumping up scores for skaters like Joubert and Plushenko? Or will Plushenko’s comments do himself in by prompting international judges to pay closer scrutiny to his, and everyone else's, program components?

The men’s competition starts next Tuesday.